November 5, 2026
Excerpt from the Council of Institutional Investors’ comment letter to the SEC dated November 5, 2026, on File No. S7-2026-32, Rescission of Rule 14a-8’s Federal Regulation of Shareholder Proposals and Amendments to Rule 14a-4.
Dear Secretary Countryman:
The Council of Institutional Investors (CII) appreciates the opportunity to comment on the Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC or Commission) proposal to rescind Rule 14a-8 and amend Rule 14a-4 (Release). CII opposes both proposals. Our reasons and responses to the Commission’s requests for comment follow.
CII is a nonprofit, nonpartisan association of U.S. public, corporate and union employee benefit funds, other employee benefit plans, state and local entities charged with investing public assets, and foundations and endowments with combined assets under management of approximately $5.6 trillion. Our member funds include major long-term shareowners with a duty to protect the retirement savings of millions of workers and their families, including public pension funds with more than 15 million participants – true and real “Main Street” investors through their pension funds.
Executive Summary
CII’s membership-approved policies state: “The ability to submit and vote on shareholder proposals is a fundamental right and allows investors to monitor and hold corporate management accountable.” Consistent with that policy, CII opposes the proposed rescission of Rule 14a-8 and the related amendments to Rule 14a-4(c). The proposal would eliminate a process that for more than 80 years has let shareholders put qualifying proposals before their fellow investors, and would leave companies and investors to sort out uncertain state-law and company-specific procedures. The rule benefits investors who vote on proposals, not only those who file them.
The Commission has not established that Section 14(a) prevents it from requiring companies to include qualifying shareholder proposals in their proxy solicitations. Federal rules governing solicitation procedures need not determine whether a proposal is binding under state corporate law. Rule 14a-8 already recognizes state-law limitations. The Commission must address the relevant case law, the position it took in litigation as recently as 2023 and the reliance interests built up over decades. Any policy case for rescission must stand on its own.
Experience supports keeping the rule. Shareholder proposals helped make annual director elections, majority voting and effective clawback policies on unearned executive compensation common practice. In addition, many prompted productive company-investor dialogues that led to mutual agreements on salutary governance reforms without ever going to votes. A 2013 proposal by the New York City pension funds, for example, led to a stronger Wells Fargo clawback policy, which the board later used to recover $60 million from two senior executives. After the Florida State Board of Administration and another investor submitted declassification proposals for the 2011 proxy season, 21 of the 25 S&P 500 companies involved moved to annual director elections, a change that research links to higher shareholder value. These benefits build over years. The Commission should weigh them, along with the cost of pushing investors toward independent campaigns, litigation and votes against directors, before eliminating the rule. See our response to Request for Comment 3.
Neither new communication technologies nor private meetings with management give shareholders what Rule 14a-8 does: a chance to put an issue to a vote of all shareholders. Rescission would split the process into state-by-state and company-by-company rules and shift costs to investors. CII favors retaining the current Rule 14a-4(c) framework and opposes the proposed check box approach, which would expand management’s discretionary voting authority and risk confusing shareholders.
If the Commission were to consider targeted refinements to the federal shareholder proposal process as an alternative to the wholesale attack on shareholder voice contemplated by the Release, CII would support revisiting only the three procedural subjects addressed by the 2020 final rule: (1) proposal eligibility based on ownership and holding periods; (2) the limit on the number of proposals submitted at a company meeting; and (3) resubmission thresholds. Any changes should be proposed separately for public comment and supported by a complete assessment of costs, benefits and reliance interests.